The best and worst Honda Pilot models have been highlighted in this guide through comparisons between 2003 and 2015.
Be sure to choose a Honda Pilot model year that is better than the worst. Here is a guide to help you determine which Honda Pilot model years are the best and worst.
To find the best and worst model years of this popular SUV, we analyzed real-world data and conducted extensive research.
Based on reliability ratings, maintenance costs, and owner comments, we have meticulously compiled and categorized every Honda Pilot model year.
As we progress through this article, we’ll discuss Honda Pilot’s best and worst features, as well as potential problems.
Your next Honda Pilot purchase will be more informed if you have this information at hand.
Let’s begin.
Honda Pilot Generations
Honda Pilot SUVs have been reliable since 2003, when they were introduced as family SUVs. Aside from its spacious interior and robust performance, the car’s safety features have made it very popular with consumers.
Following is a brief overview of this SUV’s generations to give you a better understanding of its evolution:
| Generation | Years |
| 4th generation (YG 1/2) | 2023 to Present |
| 3rd generation (YF 5/6) | 2016 to 2022 |
| 2nd generation (YF 3/4) | 2009 to 2015 |
| 1st generation (YF 1/2) | 2003 to 2008 |
Each generation brings with it changes and updates that must be considered when choosing the right generation for your needs.
Honda Pilot Best, Neutral and Worst Years
Several factors are considered in our ranking and categorization process, including:
Listed below are the Best, Neutral, and Worst Years for each team:
| Generation | Best Years | Neutral Years | Worst Years |
| 3rd generation (YF 5/6) | 2018 2020 | 2019 2021 2022 | 2016 2017 |
| 2nd generation (YF 3/4) | 2009 2015 | 2012 2013 2014 | 2010 2011 |
| 1st generation (YF 1/2) | 2006 | 2007 | 2003 2004 2005 2008 |
These are the years in which neither the good nor the bad shine. The performance and reliability of these products are average, with no notable issues or outstanding features.
The reliability of a vehicle can be impacted by negative factors such as a high NHTSA rating.
Each generation’s best, neutral, and worst years will be explored in the following paragraphs.
Honda Pilot 4th Generation [2023]
With the new Honda Pilot generation, the bar for its class will be raised and numerous advancements will be made. As well as the exterior redesign, Honda has completely redesigned the interior and front fascia to reflect its latest design language.
![Honda Pilot 4th Generation [2023]](https://gearpatro.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Honda-Pilot-4th-Generation-2023-1024x576.webp)
A number of safety and technology upgrades have also been introduced by Honda. Featuring a large, high-resolution touchscreen, the 2023 Pilot offers advanced infotainment features. As standard features, passengers get Wi-Fi hotspot, Apple CarPlay, and Android Auto, allowing them to stay connected and entertained during their journey.
The Honda Sensing system has also been enhanced with a host of new safety features, such as traffic jam assist and low-speed braking control. In addition to improving the powertrain, Honda made improvements to the performance and fuel efficiency of the 2023 Pilot.
Any new model may experience teething issues, however, so potential buyers need to be aware of these. Minor production runs may encounter problems, but they are usually resolved by the following model year. A good way to stay aware of the 2023 Honda’s recalls and consumer reviews is to keep an eye on consumer reviews.
Best & Worst Years for Honda Pilot 3rd Generation [2016 to 2022]
A major redesign of the Honda Pilot third generation was introduced in 2016. Compared to its predecessor, this vehicle was more streamlined, modern, and less boxy.
![Best & Worst Years for Honda Pilot 3rd Generation [2016 to 2022]](https://gearpatro.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Best-Worst-Years-for-Honda-Pilot-3rd-Generation-2016-to-2022-1024x683.webp)
Honda introduced new technologies and performance improvements for the first time, but there were some glitches.
The Best Years: 2018, 2020
On all trim levels of the 2018 Honda Civic, Honda Sensing is standard equipment, addressing some of the issues raised in earlier generations.
The system includes features such as adaptive cruise control, lane-keeping assistance, and collision mitigation braking. The infotainment system was also upgraded to include Apple CarPlay and Android Auto.
The 2020 model adds even more enhancements to these features. The top trims of the vehicle were equipped with a 9-speed automatic transmission, which contributed to its superior fuel economy.
All Hondas are now equipped with Honda Sensing, which contributes to their high safety ratings.
The Neutral Years: 2019, 2021, 2022
Honda Pilot is available in three neutral models for 2019-2021-2022. No significant changes were made to their safety or technological features, nor were severe problems encountered.
The models provided reliable, comfortable transportation for families as well as good fuel economy and performance.
The Worst Years: 2016, 2017
In 2016, and 2017, the Honda Pilot’s third generation encountered a number of difficulties.
Among all generations, these models received the most complaints from the NHTSA.
Engines, electrical systems, and powertrains have been the subject of many complaints, adversely affecting the vehicle’s reliability.
This was a time when the design was modern and new features were introduced, but reliability issues affected the decision of potential buyers to buy.
Best & Worst Years for Honda Pilot 2nd Generation [2009 to 2015]
In 2009, Honda Pilot’s second generation was introduced with a boxier design and improved safety features.
![Best & Worst Years for Honda Pilot 2nd Generation [2009 to 2015]](https://gearpatro.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Best-Worst-Years-for-Honda-Pilot-2nd-Generation-2009-to-2015-1024x683.webp)
A spacious and comfortable interior was added to the vehicle’s towing and off-road capabilities.
The Best Years: 2009, 2015
The 2009 model was a hit as it introduced the second generation. There was also a powerful 3.5L V6 engine producing 250 horsepower along with the V6 engine.
A large cargo area, a spacious interior, and a higher fuel economy are among its strengths. Furthermore, it had advanced safety technologies, such as stability control, anti-lock brakes, and side curtain airbags.
Again, the 2015 model stood out among the second generation models. With its improved fuel economy and smoother transitions, it was equipped with a new, more efficient 6-speed automatic transmission.
Moreover, Honda’s LaneWatch feature was integrated throughout the vehicle, enhancing visibility for the driver.
The Neutral Years: 2012, 2013, 2014
For 2012, 2013 and 2014, there are no neutral years. In spite of the lack of any groundbreaking changes, the Honda Pilot continues to be a reliable, comfortable, and powerful vehicle.
Many of the features from the successful 2009 model were carried over to these models, including the powerful V6 engine and spacious interior.
The Worst Years: 2010, 2011
2010 and 2011 were the worst years for the Honda Pilot second generation.
Due to problems with the airbag and engine, the 2010 model was subject to safety concerns and reliability issues.
The 2011 model has been reported to have airbag issues, engine problems, suspension problems, and steering problems.
As a result, consumer satisfaction ratings were significantly impacted and the overall reputation of these models was damaged.
Best & Worst Years for Honda Pilot 1st Generation [2003 to 2008]
Pilot was Honda’s first-generation midsize crossover SUV when it was introduced in 2003, marking the company’s entry into the market. V6 engine and spacious interior were praises for the car, along with the smooth ride.
![Best & Worst Years for Honda Pilot 1st Generation [2003 to 2008]](https://gearpatro.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Best-Worst-Years-for-Honda-Pilot-1st-Generation-2003-to-2008-1024x683.webp)
The Best Years: 2006
It is the 2006 model that stands out from the first generation. This model has undergone a number of improvements in terms of performance and comfort. With 244 horsepower, the car also had a 3.5L V6 engine and a 5-speed automatic transmission.
Pilots from 2006 had electronic stability control and side curtain airbags, which were both innovative at the time, in addition to the rear entertainment system and navigation.
The Neutral Years: 2007
The 2007 model year is classified as neutral. Even though there were no significant changes made to the Pilot, the qualities that made it popular remained – reliable, spacious, and powerful.
However, the reputation of this model remained the same despite slight changes to the interior and exterior design.
The Worst Years: 2003, 2004, 2005, 2008
Honda Pilot models from 2003, 2004, 2005, and 2008 are considered the worst years.
In 2003, the NHTSA issued a high number of recalls due to issues with airbags, the powertrain, and the electrical system.
Moreover, a loose driver’s seat caused discomfort and safety concerns in 2004, as well as problems with the power train and airbags.
Airbags, powertrains, electronic stability control, and servicing brakes were all defective on the 2005 model.
Airbag problems also marred the otherwise reliable performance of the 2008 model.
Common Problems With The Honda Pilot
Here are some of the most common Honda Pilot problems to help you decide which model to buy.
Transmission Failures
Honda Pilots are probably most likely to experience this transmission failure problem. This problem mostly affects 2003 models, which is a good thing. However, there may be isolated transmission failures on Pilot models with other transmissions.
The most expensive repair you can make is to fix a vehicle that has a known issue, such as transmission failure. As well as making it difficult for drivers to control their cars, transmission failures can cause accidents.
Excessive Oil Consumption
One of the most common problems with SUVs is oil consumption, and the Honda Pilot has suffered from this problem in several model years. Oil consumption isn’t a big deal if you know it, but if you don’t know about it, this can become a serious problem.
When the oil level becomes too low, it can cause your vehicle to overheat.
Keeping an oil can in the trunk and topping it off every few weeks can be similar to dealing with an oil leak. Maintaining your vehicle will be difficult if you don’t reduce oil consumption.
Peeling Paint
It is more of a concern when peeling paint occurs in areas with wet weather or rust.
In spite of the fact that you don’t think peeling paint is serious enough to prevent you from purchasing a car, you may need to repaint your car at some point.
Recurring Fault Codes
Fault codes that repeat usually do not pose any danger, unless they conceal a serious issue.
These are triggered when your Pilot detects an imaginary problem. Recurring fault codes are usually easy to identify if you or your mechanic notice them. You shouldn’t take fault codes seriously because your pilot has already taught you not to, so you’re not taking them seriously because you don’t take them seriously.
You may damage your vehicle unintentionally if you interpret a legitimate fault code as a false alarm.
Fuel Injector Failure
Fuel injector failure is another Honda Pilot problem that can be costly to fix. Recent generations of Honda Pilots, especially the 2016 version, are more prone to this issue than earlier models.
Most vehicles tend to experience this issue at around 60k miles, which is when it usually shows up.
Before committing to buying a Honda Pilot, it might be a good idea to research this issue. Several thousand dollars can be spent on fixing it.
Brake Issues
According to frustrated owners, 2003-2017 Pilot models have warped brake rotors that cause vibrations when braking. It can be quite unsettling to experience these vibrations at high speeds. There have been reports of clunking noises while braking. Experts believe the problem was caused by a defective brake pad shim.
The cost of replacing a brake pad can range from $30 to $80. It will cost you $100 to $200 to replace brake rotors, not including labor.
Electrical Problems
Electricity problems are fairly common with the 2020 Pilot, but they are less common than other problems. The navigation system, the instrument panel, and the infotainment system of the 2020 model have all been reported to have electrical problems. The dashboard usually makes clicking or ticking sounds before these issues occur, according to several reports.
It is likely that loose wiring is responsible for this problem, according to Service Bulletin #A19030B. The problem was not resolved by reconnecting the wiring under the dash.
Is The Honda Pilot A Reliable Automobile?
When buying a vehicle, make sure it is reliable and is able to accomplish what you need it to do. Besides being around for a long time, the Honda Pilot is known for its reliability among its customers.
It is without a doubt a reliable vehicle, the Honda Pilot. As one of the most reliable, friendly, and comfortable vehicles in its class, the Honda Pilot has earned high marks from J.D. ‘s Power & Associates studies. Among the best cars on the market, the Honda Pilot 2021 has a reliability rating of 78 out of 100.
With its power and dependable performance, the Pilot is Honda’s largest and most comprehensive vehicle. Honda Pilot owners will also save money on maintenance as compared to some other SUVs.
Which Honda Pilot Models Are Good To Buy Used
Used cars aren’t the only thing to consider when buying one. For a used car to be a good one, it needs to be able to handle a lot of mileage, have been well taken care of, and have a lot of miles on it.
Consequently, the 2010 Honda Pilot is one of the best choices among older models. With its many modern conveniences, the 2009 model is a great investment for the long term, as its reliability has been improved.
You should be able to find a model that meets your needs between 2015-2020, with the exception of the 2016 model.
Is The Honda Pilot A Good Investment?
When you decide to resell your car, it is essential to know whether its value will remain the same. In terms of its value, the Honda Pilot is in excellent condition. During the first five years of ownership, a Honda Pilot’s price will decrease by about 40%, which makes it one of the best vehicles out there.
You would get a very fair price for your automobile if you decided to sell it. Resale values of these cars are far superior to those of similar cars; however, if you want to sell them at a profit, they must be maintained properly.
Best & Worst Honda CR-V Years | Years To Avoid
Best & Worst Honda Civic Years | Years To Avoid
Best & Worst Honda Accord Years | Years To Avoid
Best & Worst Honda Odyssey Years | Years To Avoid
Honda Pilot Firing Order For Cylinder Numbers From 2002-2015
Best & Worst Honda Fit Years | Years To Avoid
Best & Worst Honda Ridgeline Years | Years To Avoid
FAQs
Why is the 2003 Honda Pilot model particularly notorious?
Transmission failures are particularly common among 2003 Honda Pilot models, one of the most costly repairs a vehicle can undergo. Failures in transmissions can lead to serious financial burdens and safety concerns.
What makes the brake issues in Honda Pilot models between 2003 and 2017 notable?
There have been reports of vibrations and potential unsettling sounds during braking in Honda Pilots due to warped brake rotors. Although the affected components can usually be repaired, it can be costly to repair brake rotors.
Are Honda Pilots typically reliable?
The Honda Pilot is not a model that lives up to Honda’s reputation for making excellent vehicles. It’s best to stay away from 2003, 2005, 2009, 2011, 2013, and 2016 model years.
How much does a used Honda Pilot typically cost?
Honda Pilots have been produced in 20 versions, and early models with high mileage can fetch three thousand dollars or more. It is better to choose a newer Pilot if you need reliability.
When it comes to dependability, the 2019 Honda Pilot gets a good grade. The typical price of this vehicle is $30,968, according to CoPilot Price Pulse. It represents a 16% premium due to modest inventories and high demand.
Which Honda Pilot years should potential buyers avoid?
The following Honda Pilot model years should be avoided: 2003, 2005, 2009, 2011, 2013, and 2016. These years are often criticized for their reliability and consistency issues.
What are the most common problems associated with problematic Honda Pilot models?
Transmission problems, excessive oil consumption, peeling paint, recurring fault codes, fuel injector failures, brake problems, and electrical problems are more likely to occur during these years.
Is the Honda Pilot a good car to purchase?
Choosing a pre-owned Honda Pilot that comes from a reliable source is a smart move. The Honda Pilot is at its best during these model years.
Conclusion
You will now have a much easier time choosing the right Honda Pilot model year for you. Your knowledge of the newest Pilot models will grow as time passes.
In your own experience, how has the Honda Pilot performed? Are there any particular generations or years that you enjoy most?
Your insights will be very helpful to those who intend to purchase a Honda Pilot. Feel free to share your thoughts and experiences in the comments section.