Best & Worst Toyota Highlander Years

Make sure you don’t make the costly mistake of purchasing a Toyota Highlander from a year that wasn’t good. Here is a list of Toyota Highlander years that you should avoid.

There is no question that the Toyota Highlander is one of the most competitive midsize crossover SUVs on the market today.

Despite its reliability, comfort, and well-rounded features, it has endured years of ups and downs.

Best & Worst Toyota Highlander Years [Models]

Potential purchasers can gain a comprehensive understanding of the highest and lowest Toyota Highlander years from this manual.

It’s time to get started.

Toyota Highlander Generations

Generation	Years
Toyota Highlander (XU70, 4th generation)	2020 to Present
Toyota Highlander (XU50, 3rd generation)	2014 to 2019
Toyota Highlander (XU40, 2nd generation)	2008 to 2013
Toyota Highlander (XU20, 1st generation)	2001 to 2007

Toyota Highlander generations are shown in the table above, giving you a clear picture of the model’s development. A buying decision can be greatly influenced by key changes in design, functionality, and technology between each generation.

The term “Neutral Year” refers to model years that do not deviate significantly from the established norm. Neither the features nor the issues of these years stand out as exceptional.

Those are average years, if you will.

Toyota Highlander Best, Neutral, and Worst Years

Generation	Best Years	Neutral Years	Worst Years
4th (2020-Present)	2020	2021	2022 2023
3rd (2014-2019)	2014 2016 2017 2018	2015	2019
2nd (2008-2013)	2009 2011 2012	2013	2008 2010
1st (2001-2007)	2003 2004 2005 2006	2002	2001 2007

Based on a dozen hours of research, these categorizations include reliability scores reported by owners, maintenance costs, safety ratings, Consumer Reports reliability ratings and owner satisfaction scores, recalls, complaints, investigations, and Edmunds, JD Power, Kelley’s Blue Book (KBB), VehicleHistory, and Cars.com owner ratings.

These rankings can be affected by some factors. Model years with a high number of NHTSA recalls may have lower reliability, thus lowering their score.

The classifications are now set, let’s explore each generation’s best and worst years.

Best & Worst Years For Toyota Highlander 4th Generation [2020 to Present]

In 2020, the Highlander received a fourth-generation redesign and offered advanced technology.

2020 is the best year

Featuring a robust V6 engine, spacious interior, and a comprehensive set of driver assistance features, the 2020 model set a high standard for the new generation of vehicles.

Also improved by the redesign was the exterior’s style and the cabin’s quietness. The Highlander Hybrid, which offers impressive fuel economy, is the true distinguishing feature of the 2020 model.

2021 is the neutral year

The 2021 Highlander was a strong midsize SUV competitor, but it didn’t offer significant improvements over its predecessor.

In spite of its high safety scores and comfortable interior, there were complaints about its finicky infotainment system.

2022 and 2023 are the worst years

This model year has received some criticism despite being recent. There have been reports of problems with the infotainment system, such as freezing screens or automatic reboots.

There were also minor mechanical issues reported with the brakes and transmission, placing them in the “worst” category.

Best & Worst Years For Toyota Highlander 3rd Generation [2014 to 2019]

In 2014, the third-generation Highlander debuted with enhanced power, enhanced safety features, and a more premium interior.

The best years were 2014, 2016, 2017, and 2018

In addition to their reliability and performance, these models were also known for their luxurious interiors. With the introduction of a more efficient transmission, the Highlander’s fuel economy was improved, while its tech features were made more user-friendly.

Pre-collision warnings and lane departure warnings are part of Toyota’s Safety Sense package, which is another plus.

2015 is the neutral year

Highlander’s 2015 model didn’t display significant advancements or significant issues. Despite maintaining the 2014 model’s high standards, it did not exceed them.

Its reputation for smooth rides and decent infotainment was marred by some reported glitches in the infotainment system.

The worst year was 2019

As well as some reported transmission issues and abrupt shifts, the 2019 model was criticized for a relatively less engaging driving experience.

In spite of its premium interior and standard safety features, this car is ranked lower due to these drawbacks.

Best & Worst Years For Toyota Highlander 2nd Generation [2008 to 2013]

In 2008, the second-generation Highlander was launched with an improved design that was larger and more family-friendly.

The best years were 2009, 2011, and 2012

With high reliability and spacious three-row seating, the 2009, 2011, and 2012 models were ideal for large families.

This engine provided an excellent balance of power and fuel efficiency because it was equipped with a powerful 3.5-liter V6 engine. Their appeal was further enhanced by enhanced safety features such as traction control and improved crash safety ratings.

2013 is the neutral year

This model’s reliability and interior space were generally good, but it didn’t stand out in comparison to other years.

This model year fell short of a higher ranking due to minor issues with electric power steering and occasional transmission hiccups.

The worst years were 2008 and 2010

Engine issues such as excessive oil consumption plagued the 2008 model, which ushered in the second generation.

Owners reported problems with the interior electronics, including navigation systems that did not work and temperature control problems. Similar problems were reported with the 2010 model, along with premature brake wear and body integrity issues.

Best & Worst Years For Toyota Highlander 1st Generation [2001 to 2007]

Originally launched in 2001, Toyota’s Highlander is a dependable and cosy midsize SUV.

2003, 2004, 2005, 2006 are the best years

In these years, the first generation showed exceptional reliability, comfort, and cargo capacity.

With the introduction of the 3.3-liter V6 engine in 2004, towing capacity was greatly enhanced, while fuel efficiency was maintained.

Furthermore, airbag systems and stability control were introduced during this period, as well as enhanced safety features.

2002 was a neutral year

Performance and reliability were decent on the 2002 model. There were minor issues with the engine, specifically coolant leaks and oxygen sensor failures, which prevented it from achieving the “best” ranking.

These minor drawbacks balanced its strengths, such as ample interior space and a comfortable ride.

The worst years were 2001 and 2007

Transmission problems and air conditioning system failures plagued the 2001 model in its debut year. The company’s reputation was tarnished by these issues, which resulted in an increase in owner-reported problems.

It was widely criticized for its subpar interior quality and uninspiring handling in 2007, which marked an end to an otherwise strong generation.

Common Issues With The Toyota Highlander

Listed below are some of the most common Toyota Highlander problems to avoid.

Engine Bolts Becoming Stripped

In the event that you don’t catch the problem early, it can become a serious problem. Coolant leakage and overheated engines are the most common indicators of stripped engine bolts.

If your engine has not already suffered other damage due to overheating, the bolts can be replaced and the bolt holes can be redrilled. Many people who encountered this problem had no choice but to replace their engines completely.

There is a high likelihood of this problem recurring after 130k miles, but it can occur more than once.

Engine Failure

The engine failure issue is also a significant problem with Toyota Highlanders. Overheating problems are probably a cause of those failures, but other problems can occur as well.

The combination of those factors means you’re more likely to need to replace your engine if you buy a Toyota Highlander from a problem year.

The problem of an engine failure is one that only some car owners are willing to repair, so you should also consider whether you have the resources to replace your engine or whether you would need to buy a new vehicle.

Most engine failures occur around 120k miles, but can occur earlier in some cases. It is possible that some Highlanders will pass 120k miles without any problems, but later on there may be problems.

Using Engine Oil Faster Than Average

Toyota Highlanders are known for using oil, and sadly, they are one of them. The problem can occur with almost any Highlander model, but it is more common in recent years.

In spite of the fact that 2002 is considered to be a solid car, it burns through engine oil most rapidly. Considering this, we wouldn’t worry about this problem too much in a 2002 Highlander if you’re okay with paying a little extra for oil. It may be more of a problem if you are considering another model year with known issues.

Fuel Tank and AC Condenser Problems

Critics and consumers both liked the 2020 Highlander redesigned, but it had some reliability problems. It was reported that the 2020 model’s fuel tank had issues.

According to reports, the tank was not able to be filled to its advertised 17.1 gallons capacity. Gas was only able to be filled up to the extent of 12-14 gallons.

There are also reports that suggest the Highlander’s air conditioning system may be hit-or-miss. In this case, the AC condenser was prone to damage, and as a result, the air conditioner stopped working. Condensers can be replaced for $60 to $150, including labor, which is a simple fix.

Faulty Head Gasket and Oxygen Sensor

In 2001-2007 Highlander models, the engine overheats quite often. It is believed that blown head gaskets are responsible for the engine overheating. When the head bolts are tightened, the threads pull out of the engine block, ultimately resulting in a blown head gasket.

There have also been reports of faulty oxygen sensors on several Highlander models. There is a defect in the engine that causes it to misfire and idle rough.

Which Models Of Toyota Highlander Are Great To Buy Used?

In our previous section, we listed a number of used models that are good choices, but some are better than others. It is our recommendation that you consider the 2010 model if you want a nice deal on a larger, more spacious model than others. There are a few more problem reports for models between 2009 and 2011, but they are still a good choice.

For those looking for a more recent model and don’t mind paying a bit more, the 2016, 2017, and 2018 models offer great value and good performance. It is too early to recommend the 2019 and 2020 models as used vehicles, but they appear to be good options for used vehicles as well.

Best & Worst Toyota Camry Years | Years To Avoid
Best & Worst Toyota RAV4 Years (Years To Avoid)
Best & Worst Toyota Tacoma Years | Years To Avoid
Best & Worst Toyota Corolla Years | Years To Avoid
Best & Worst Toyota Sienna Years | Years To Avoid
Best & Worst Toyota Tundra Years | Years To Avoid
Best & Worst Toyota 4Runner Years | Years To Avoid
Best & Worst Toyota Sienna Years | Years To Avoid
Best & Worst Toyota Prius Years | Years To Avoid
Best & Worst Toyota Avalon Years | Years To Avoid

Frequently Asked Questions

What Toyota Highlander years should I avoid in the used car market?

It is recommended that you avoid the Toyota Highlander model years 2003, 2008, 2014, and 2015. There are more significant issues with these models than with other years.

Were there any Toyota Highlander models with notable engine problems?

Certain Toyota Highlander models have experienced engine bolts becoming stripped, causing coolant leaks and overheating, which sometimes necessitated complete engine replacements. Around 130,000 miles, these problems began to occur.

Has Toyota addressed the fuel tank issue in the 2020 Highlander model?

Fuel tanks in the 2020 Highlander were not filling to their advertised capacity, which Toyota has acknowledged. If a fuel tank assembly or design anomaly is discovered, dealer service actions may be necessary to rectify it.

Which model years offer the best balance between cost and reliability for a used Toyota Highlander?

A good balance of cost and reliability can be found in the models from 2001, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2009 through 2013, as well as more recent models from 2017 to 2021. There are fewer severe issues that plague these years than other models, and they are generally regarded as good investments.

Are Toyota Highlanders typically reliable?

With more than 20 years of experience in the U.S., Toyota’s Highlander has been a trusted family hauler. The Toyota Highlander has an excellent reputation for reliability in most model years except 2003, 2008, 2014, and 2015.

How much does a used Toyota Highlander typically cost?

Older Highlanders, such as those from 2002 with 100,000 miles, cost about $6,000. In demand vehicles cause prices to rise quickly on newer examples. The price of a 2012 Highlander may be doubled or tripled depending on its condition and equipment.

Almost-new Highlanders are selling at new car prices as a result of a tight market. The asking price for a 2020 Toyota Highlander is $38,158, according to CoPilot Price Pulse. The price is 17% higher than it would be during regular market conditions.

Is the Toyota Highlander a good car to purchase?

Yes, of course. There is no better choice for a three-row crossover than the Toyota Highlander. It is a safe bet to buy a used Toyota Highlander as most model years are reliable (here are the most reliable Toyota Highlander years). New Highlanders come with a warranty, which gives you extra peace of mind.

Conclusion

Toyota Highlanders have evolved intricately through the generations, but generally in an impressive way. You can make more informed purchasing decisions if you know which years are best for the model.

The Toyota Highlander’s most and least favorable years are examined in this guide, focusing on reliability, maintenance, safety, and consumer satisfaction.

What is your favorite Toyota Highlander model year? We’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments below.

Best & Worst Toyota Highlander Years | Years To Avoid